(Photo by Frank Rizzo)
Emeritus is an honorific commonly associated with retired college professors, but there is nothing retiring about Arthur Dobrin of Westbury.
A professor at Hofstra University for 32 years, Dobrin has for the past decade taught at least one and sometimes two media ethics classes at the campus as an adjunct. They are required for the various degree paths at the Lawrence Herbert School of Communication.
But his association with the institution may have come to an end after his lawyer, Thomas F. Liotti of Garden City, filed a complaint with the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) “alleging a breach of contract, age discrimination and a failure to accommodate his medical condition during this pandemic by not allowing him to teach his students remotely by Zoom.”
When the university closed down in March under Governor Andrew Cuomo’s emergency orders, Dobrin related, his class transitioned to Zoom.
“It was much better than I expected,” Dobrin, 77, said. “And we finished out the semester. I was delightfully surprised. It was not as good as in-person teaching, but much better than I anticipated.”
His classes are usually capped at 30 students, Dobrin noted.
According to the narrative he wrote for the EEOC:
“I was scheduled to teach one of three media ethics sections for the fall 2020 semester. After creating the syllabus, arranging for guest speakers and communicating with students who were already registered for my section, I was informed that the course must be taught in-person.
“I proposed that my section be a distance learning class. That was rejected our of hand, although my spring class successfully had ended on Zoom. The at-distance alternative would not be discussed. A medical accommodation was irrelevant. This is an unreasonable and unethical stance. My class was one of three sections on media ethics and it could have presented as the section for those students who would choose not to return to campus.”
Dobrin said he was informed weeks before the semester began that he was required to teach in person.
“My cardiologist said, ‘You’re crazy. You’re not going back into the classroom. You shouldn’t be doing this, not at your age.’ So I said to [the department] ‘I’ll do it remote. It worked reasonably well in the spring.’ They said, ‘Nope. Sorry, no discussion possible.’”
Asked if his experience was unique, Dobrin revealed that another colleague faced similar circumstances, but was not interested in pursuing charges with the EEOC, hoping to “keep the door open” with the institution.
Asked if he would ever teach again at Hofstra, Dobrin replied, “It may be that they will not have a need for me. Or if they do have a need they might say, ‘Look, he’s lost his place on the [line].’ I have no idea. I love teaching, and I like being in the classroom, but again, the point wasn’t if I was or wasn’t going to teach the class. The point was, you don’t get rid of people this way. For me, it’s a matter of principle.”
He added, “I’m friends with a number of colleagues. One friend was more outraged than I was. He said, ‘What? How can they do that?’ He thought it was totally unconscionable.”
“Why do you feel you can win your case?” Liotti was asked.
“For a number of reasons,” he replied. “There are all kinds of precedents around the country now, teaching virtually, including at Harvard and elsewhere. It’s the way to go. And when you have a professor who’s been teaching at Hofstra for [32] years and he’s got a pre-existing medical condition that would really prevent him from being on site, so to speak, to teach his students directly. He’s done remote teaching before at Hofstra and it was approved and there were no complaints.”
Liotti added, “Arthur is a veteran teacher and he’s loved by his students. So this development was really shocking. It was really unfair to him after all his service to Hofstra.”
Karla Schuster, assistant vice president at the Office of University Relations, said the university could not comment.
“I love being in the classroom. I love being around young people. I find it stimulating. I think I have something to offer. If you look at the Rate My Professor [website] you’ll see I [got good marks.] It was all a plus,” Dobrin concluded.
