Who Makes The Best Egg Sandwich on Long Island?

egg sandwich
egg sandwich

A proper bacon, egg, and cheese on a roll (with salt, pepper and ketchup, of course) is as hotly debated as pizza and bagels around here. So, who makes the best egg sandwich on Long Island?

Long Islanders voted Druthers Coffee the Best Egg Sandwich on Long Island in the 2022 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest!

The Druthers Egg Sandwich is a staple item at this Stony Brook coffee shop. Launching the food menu in 2020, Druthers Coffee was particularly proud of their egg sandwich. The eggs, locally produced from Raleighs Poultry Farm, are topped with smoked cheddar, crispy shallots, and Calabrian chili aioli. All this deliciousness is placed on an everything bagel from Black Seed Bagels in Brooklyn. Regulars have called the Druthers Egg Sandwich “crazy good” and “the best egg sandwich you can find on Long Island.”

Druthers Coffee is located at 1113 North Country Rd., Building 5, in Stony Brook. It can be reached at 631-364-9667 or druthers.coffee

To find all the other 2022 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest winners, visit bestoflongisland.com Nominate your favorite businesses and people in the 2023 contest through Aug. 15.

To read more Best of Long Island Spotlights, visit longislandpress.com/category/boli-spotlight.

Sign up for Long Island Press’ email newsletters hereSign up for home delivery of Long Island Press here. Sign up for discounts by becoming a Long Island Press community partner here