Historic Garden City ‘Disciple’ Victorian Asks $1.8M


One of the few remaining so-called “disciple” homes is listed for sale at 110 9th St. in Garden City, offering a rare opportunity to own a Victorian that’s among the earliest houses built in the village.

Built in 1888 on a nearly half-acre lot, this magnificent five-bedroom home has four and a half bathrooms and 4,200 square feet of living space. It’s listed on the National Register of Historic Places and is part of the A.T. Stewart Era Historic District, named for the community’s founder. 

The house boasts custom milled flooring, moldings, and custom windows that match the original circa of this home. It features a chef’s kitchen with custom cabinetry and white Carrera marble counter tops. It also has a gracious formal living room with two marble fireplaces, a sunlit family room that leads to a formal dining room, and a home office.

It has a finished third-floor walkup plus a pull-down attic for storage. The partially finished basement has a family room, summer kitchen, bathroom, laundry room, and entrance to the backyard patio and lush yard. Outside it has a three-car garage.

The property is located within walking distance of downtown Garden City, the Garden City Long Island Rail Road station, and falls in the highly ranked Garden City School District. 

The asking price is $1,880,000, not including the annual property taxes of $23,639.

The real estate agents listed for the property are Maggie MacRae and Lori Ann Dredger of Signature Premier Properties, who can be reached at 516-741-4333.3254500 23254500 33254500 43254500 53254500 63254500 73254500 83254500 93254500 103254500 113254500 123254500 133254500 143254500 153254500 163254500 173254500 183254500 193254500 20

Related Story: Garden City: The Beating Heart of Nassau

For more real estate news, visit longislandpress.com/category/real-estate

Sign up for Long Island Press’ email newsletters hereSign up for home delivery of Long Island Press here. Sign up for discounts by becoming a Long Island Press community partner here.