Who Makes The Best French Toast on Long Island?

French Toast
Getty Images

The perfect plate of French toast is fluffy and tender on the inside and perfectly browned on the outside, but which local restaurant makes this popular breakfast dish best?

Long Islanders voted Buttermilk’s Kitchen Best French Toast on Long Island in the 2020 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest!

If your answer in the whole pancakes vs. waffles debate is to skip both of those and go right for French toast, Buttermilk’s Kitchen in Patchogue is the place for you. For more than 25 years, Buttermilk’s Kitchen has strived to be your home away from home. In addition to their classic brioche French toast, Buttermilk’s Kitchen puts a unique spin on their French toast offerings.

Their BFP French toast is topped with bananas, peanut butter and fluff. The bananas foster French toast is smothered in flambeed bananas and whipped cream. The Smores French toast? You guessed it — French toast stuffed with fluff and chocolate, topped with crushed up graham crackers, chocolate and toasted marshmallows.

Don’t forget to try their Holy Cannoli French toast or their French toast bites!

Buttermilk’s Kitchen is located at 76 W. Main St. in Patchogue. It can be reached at 631-654-MILK or buttermilkskitchen.com

To find all the other 2020 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest winners, visit bestoflongisland.com Vote for your favorite businesses and people in the 2021 Bethpage Best of Long Island program Oct. 1 through Dec. 15.

To read more Best of Long Island Spotlights, visit longislandpress.com/category/boli-spotlight

Sign up for Long Island Press’ email newsletters hereSign up for home delivery of Long Island Press here. Sign up for discounts by becoming a Long Island Press community partner here.