Who Makes The Best Specialty Pizza on Long Island?

Italian pizza in a restaurant display window in Rome
Getty Images

Now there’s pizza, and then there’s pizza. We’re not talking about pizza with just a few toppings thrown on, we’re talking about pizza with the works. But who makes the best specialty pizza on Long Island?

Long Islanders voted Grandpa Tony’s the Best Specialty Pizza on Long Island in the 2021 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest!

Have you ever heard of a Quatro Fromaggi? Mozzarella, provolone, pecorino Romano and fontina are the stars. It’s a specialty pizza at Grandpa Tony’s where even the most persnickety foodie will gloat helplessly if asked, “How is it?” The cozy, Italian eatery makes the best wood-fired pizza in town. Pies come out steaming hot and you can barely wait for the smoke to evaporate before biting into yours. The eatery’s namesake, Little Tony is a breeze with cheese you’ll want to devour. This one has roasted peppers cooked in the brick oven, sausage, tomato sauce, and fresh garlic with mozzarella. The 800-degree wood-fired oven produces the best well-done pizzas around.

Grandpa Tony’s is located at 101 Althouse Ave. in East Rockaway. It can be reached at 516-799-8669 or grandpatonysli.com

To find all the other 2021 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest winners, visit bestoflongisland.com Voting has now ended in the 2022 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest and winners will be announced soon. Nominate your favorite businesses and people in the 2023 contest through Aug. 15.

To read more Best of Long Island Spotlights, visit longislandpress.com/category/boli-spotlight

Sign up for Long Island Press’ email newsletters hereSign up for home delivery of Long Island Press here. Sign up for discounts by becoming a Long Island Press community partner here.