12 Long Island Reality TV Personalities

Reality television attracts some of the most talented, eccentric, and entertaining characters out there. So it’s no surprise that some are from Long Island. 

Whether they were singing for celebrity judges, trying to make a romantic connection, or partying with a houseful of 20-to-30-somethings, these 12 Long Islanders entered the spotlight as national, reality TV personalities when their respective shows aired.

Carter Rubin (The Voice)

NUP 192429 4234 e1609449544132
Carter Rubin (Photo by Trae Patton/NBC)

In most recent memory, 15-year-old Carter Rubin stole the hearts of America when he won NBC’s The Voice in December 2020. The Shoreham teen competed on pop star Gwen Stefani’s team after she and singer-songwriter John Legend turned their chairs for him in his blind audition.

Melanie Martinez (The Voice)

1280px Melanie martinez
Photo courtesy Wikimedia Commons

Melanie Martinez was also a contestant on The Voice, in 2012. Though she didn’t win, she made it to the top 6 on Maroon 5 frontman Adam Levine’s team. Since then, the 25-year-old Baldwin native has released two albums and gained a strong following of young people.

Dr. Joe Park (The Bachelorette)

In 2020, Dr. Joe Park, an anesthesiologist from Valley Stream, vied for the love and attention of bachelorette Tayshia Adams on The Bachelorette. Unfortunately, Adams gave other eligible bachelors roses, and Park was eliminated in the seventh episode.

Tara Costa (The Biggest Loser)

Bethpage’s Tara Costa earned third place on The Biggest Loser in 2009 by losing an impressive 155 pounds and breaking a record for number of challenges won on the show. She now works as a fitness coach.

Tommy Sheehan (Survivor)

114722 D8626b
Tommy Sheehan on SURVIVOR: Island of Idols. Photo: Michele Crowe/CBS Entertainment ©2019 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Tommy Sheehan, an elementary school teacher from Long Beach, became the sole survivor of Survivor: Island of the Idols in 2020. Although he never won an immunity challenge, a physical or mental obstacle, which, if won, keeps a contestant safe from being voted out for a night, he navigated the social aspect of the game right to the end.

Theresa Caputo (Long Island Medium)

caputo 222 resized
‘Long Island Medium’ Theresa Caputo

Never has a reality show publicized one Long Islander’s life to the extremes of Long Island Medium. On it, Theresa Caputo uses her self-described abilities to speak with those who have passed to comfort their grieving families. Some deny her credibility, but they can’t argue that her overblown enthusiasm makes for entertaining television.

Sal “The Voice” Valentinetti (America’s Got Talent)

Crooner Sal Valentinetti took the country by storm with his renditions of songs such as Frank Sinatra’s “My Way” and “You Make Me Feel So Young.” The Bethpage native finished in fifth place on the show’s 11th season.

Jenni “JWoww” Farley (Jersey Shore)

File:JWoww 2010.jpg - Wikimedia Commons
Photo courtesy Wikimedia Commons

Jenni “JWoww” Farley was living in Franklin Square when she auditioned, and secured her place, on Jersey Shore. She’s gone on to star in other spin-off reality shows, such as Snooki & JWoww, Snooki & JWoww: Moms with Attitude, Jenni & Roger Domesticated, and Jersey Shore: Family Vacation.

Robbie Rosen (American Idol)

AMERICAN IDOL; Top 24: Robbie Rosen performs in front of the judges on AMERICAN IDOL airing Tuesday, March 1, (8:00-10:00 PM ET/PT) on FOX. CR: Michael Becker / FOX
Robbie Rosen performs in front of the judges on American Idol airing Tuesday, March 1, 2011 on FOX. (Michael Becker/FOX)

Merrick native Robbie Rosen was 17 when he competed on American Idol in 2011. His Calhoun High School classmates cheered him on all the way until the wild card round, when he was eliminated from the competition.

Kevin Covais (American Idol)

Kevin Covais, who hails from Levittown, competed on American Idol in 2006. He was eliminated after making it to the top 11 singers. Some fellow contestants called him “Chicken Little,” joking that he resembled the animated film character.

Jared Cotter (American Idol)

Oceanside’s Jared Cotter was eliminated from American Idol after competing among the top 16 contestants on the show in 2007. 

Amanda Zuckerman (Big Brother)

This Port Washington native stirred up controversy on season 15 of Big Brother. The show is notoriously known for bringing tons of housemate drama, and she was there for it. She placed seventh and became the fifth player on “the jury.”

Related article: Unpolished: Long Island’s Latest Reality Show Debuts Sunday on TLC

For more entertainment coverage, visit longislandpress.com/category/entertainment.

Sign up for Long Island Press’ email newsletters hereSign up for home delivery of Long Island Press here. Sign up for discounts by becoming a Long Island Press community partner here.