Light-filled, Gatsby-era Brick Home in Southold Asks $2.2M


A waterfront, Gatsby-era brick house with lots of natural light is listed for sale at 200 Harbor Lights Dr. in Southold.

This Georgian manor home was built in 1925 and originally belonged to a 100-acre estate. Now part of a .86-acre property for sale, the house has been restored and still holds its Gatsby-esque, 1920s charm.

Part of the Harbor Lights waterfront community, there are some peaceful views of the bay from behind the home’s many tall windows. The house’s large, screened-in porch is also a great place to dine, relax, and enjoy the scenery.

The house has five bedrooms, four bathrooms, and two half bathrooms. According to the listing, the home is “restored to its original grandeur” with a slate roof, an updated, modern kitchen with marble countertops, a formal living room and dining room with their own fireplaces, a butler’s pantry, and a breakfast room.

The home also features guest quarters, a den/family room, home office, walk-in closets, and powder room.

The asking price is $2,200,000, not including the annual property tax of $15,640.

The real estate agents listed for the property are Marie Beninati and Lee Beninati, of Beninati Associates, who can be reached at 631-765-5333.

3301795 2 3301795 35 3301795 27 3301795 24 3301795 23 3301795 22 3301795 22 1 3301795 20 3301795 19 3301795 18 3301795 17 3301795 16 3301795 14 3301795 13 3301795 12 3301795 11 3301795 10 3301795 8 3301795 8 1 3301795 7 3301795 6 3301795 5 3301795 4 3301795 3For more real estate news, visit longislandpress.com/category/real-estate.

Sign up for Long Island Press’ email newsletters here. Sign up for home delivery of Long Island Press here. Sign up for discounts by becoming a Long Island Press community partner here.