10 Most Unique Gift Shops on Long Island

gift shops on long island
Getty Images

10 Most Unique Gift Shops on Long Island

Charles Krypell Fine Jewelry
25 Northern Blvd., Greenvale
Jewelry — Seventy percent of the store’s stock is Charles’ designs, while the rest are other jewelry brands of his choosing.

Di Angela Leather
140 Main St., Greenport
Leather goods — Whether it’s handbags, jewelry, shoes, jackets, accessories or briefcases that are sought, if it’s made of leather, this shop has it.

Dolphin Bookshop
299 Main St., Port Washington
Books — This independently owned bookstore’s shelves are filled with the gift of knowledge, plus it hosts book signings, for those looking to get their book personalized before wrapping it.

37 E Main St., Babylon
Personal and home accessories — Launched as a mobile shop operating out of a camper at live events, this unique store debuted its fixed location supporting more than 70 local artisans to offer an array of unique handmade goods.

Land of Oohs & Oz
155 Main St., Farmingdale
Toys — In addition to an array of toys new and retro, this shop also is well stocked in comic books, models, collectibles, and antiques.

Paper Doll Vintage Boutique
23 Main St., Sayville
Women’s attire — This one-of-a-kind vintage boutique and curiosity shoppe specializes in unique finds. It also offers vintage and retro mystery boxes, for those who like a surprise.

St. James General Store
516 Moriches Rd., St. James
General — In keeping with its history, the store preserves the experience of shopping in an 1800s general store, upgraded to offer modern patrons an expertly curated selection of fine gifts, books, toys, food, and confections.

The Giftologist
37 S. Park Ave., Rockville Centre
Home and personal accessories — This shop has the art of gift giving down to a science, with its ecletic collection of accessories, clothing, personalized engraving and more.

Willis Hobbies
300 Willis Ave., Mineola
Hobby — This sprawling hobby shop boasts an expansive selection of fun, including radio-controlled cars, boats, and aircraft, model trains, slot cars, rockets, drones, and more.

Willy Nilly Trading Company
153 W. Main St., Bay Shore
Personal and home accessories — From hard-to-find items to popular merchandise, this inviting shop caters to eclectic tastes with its ever-changing selection.

Sign up for Long Island Press’ email newsletters here. Sign up for home delivery of Long Island Press here. Sign up for discounts by becoming a Long Island Press community partner here.