Who Makes The Best Grilled Cheese on Long Island?

Grilled Cheese
Getty Images

A grilled cheese sandwich is one of those simple delights that can’t be beat, but when the craving for one strikes, which of the many local restaurants to choose from makes the best grilled cheese on Long Island?

Long Islanders voted Hops Scotch Bottle Shop the Best Grilled Cheese on Long Island in the 2022 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest!

Not only is Hops Scotch Bottle Shop a prime spot for tasting local, independent craft beers, it’s also a great place to eat. And of course, comfort food is on the menu. When it comes to grilled cheese, Long Islanders have found something special at Hops Scotch Bottle Shop and have voted it the best grilled cheese on Long Island.

With the bread grilled and cheese melted to perfection, it is the only bar food you’ll want to pair with the many beers, wines, ciders, and meads that this beer garden has to offer. Or, if you’re not planning on staying and drinking, you can always order the grilled cheese – and anything else on the menu – for pickup or delivery.


Hops Scotch Bottle Shop is located at 848 Long Island Ave. in Deer Park. It can be reached at 631-492-9125 or hopsscotchny.com

To find all the other 2022 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest winners, visit bestoflongisland.com Vote for your favorite businesses and people in the 2023 contest is open until Dec. 15!