East Setauket Colonial Farmhouse On Market For First Time Nearly A Century Asks $899,000


This beautifully restored Colonial Farmhouse loaded with charm is listed for sale for the first time in more than 85 years at 45 Main St. in East Setauket.

Built in 1843 on a magnificent two-acre lot in what is now the community’s historic district, this three-bedroom, three-bathroom home boasts high ceilings, wood floors, four fireplaces, a chicken coop, outhouse, playhouse, and shed. 

The house features an eat-in kitchen, formal dining room, den, office, parlor, full basement, and third-floor walk-up attic.

The house comes equipped with central air conditioning, gas heat, a whole house generator, and in-ground sprinklers. Outside it has a front porch, brick patio in the backyard, and detached 2.5-car garage.

The property is near local shops and restaurants, a mile from the Stony Brook Long Island Rail Road station, and falls in the Three Village School District.

The asking price is $899,000, not including the $8,723 in annual property taxes.

The real estate agent listed for the property is Michael O’Dwyer of Daniel Gale Agency Inc., who can be reached at 631-689-6980.31667663166766 13166766 43166766 33166766 53166766 63166766 73166766 83166766 93166766 103166766 113166766 123166766 133166766 143166766 153166766 163166766 173166766 183166766 19