Who Makes The Best Coffee Cake on Long Island?

Close-up piece of homemade Cinnamon crumble coffee cake and cup of milk tea. White wooden background.
Getty Images

There’s no shortage of places to score a good coffee cake, but what local restaurant makes it best?

Long Islanders voted Lindenhurst Diner the Best Coffee Cake on Long Island in the 2021 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest!

Coffee cake fans will flip for this flaky, crumbly treat at the Lindenhurst Diner. A family-owned restaurant known for its menu that’s delicious all the way through, the diner offers coffee cake with breakfast or as a scrumptious dessert. The treat is the perfect blend of hot and savory, prepared fresh daily by baker Nick. The traditional American confection is a marriage of sweet pound cake topped with brown sugar, cinnamon, and streusel. Regulars at the Lindenhurst diner love to pair it with steamy coffee after a wonderful breakfast like an egg frittata or Tex Mex scramble, or to top off a hearty dinner. Eat your cake at your table or get it to go with takeout or car hop service!

Lindenhurst Diner is located at 195 E. Montauk Hwy. Lindenhurst. It can be reached at 631-991-8600 or lindenhurstdiner.com

To find all the other 2021 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest winners, visit bestoflongisland.com Nominate your favorite businesses and people in the 2022 Best of Long Island program through Aug. 31.

Sign up for Long Island Press’ email newsletters hereSign up for home delivery of Long Island Press here. Sign up for discounts by becoming a Long Island Press community partner here.