19th-Century Home on 1 Acre of Gardens in Setauket Asks $735K


A one-of-a-kind, 19th-century home on one acre of gardens is listed for sale at 210 Old Town Rd. in Setauket.

This single family, 4-bedroom house was built in 1880. Its antique-hist architecture and decorative interior features, such as colorful stained glass windows, give the home its vibrant, old-world character. 

The property is behind a short, stone and wrought iron gate. Enter, and you’re in a 1-acre space of nature gardens with stones and fountains abound — even a pergola, small koi pond, wood bridge, and bench, which is a perfect spot for relaxing and reading a book. 

The home also has a decently-sized front porch with an overhang — another great place for lounging — plus, three garage spaces and an outbuilding with original details matching the main home, which could be used as a playhouse, garage, studio, or something else.

Inside the 1,992-square-foot house, the living room and large dining room each have a fireplace. The eat-in kitchen is updated with tile flooring and a wall tile inlay but retains its 1800s charm. The home also has two full bathrooms, an office space, and a full, unfinished basement.

The house is located in the Three Village School District.

The asking price is $735,000, not including the annual property tax of $5,086.

The real estate agent listed for the property is Miriam Ainbinder, of Daniel Gale Agency Inc., who can be reached at 631-689-6980.

3354917 35 3354917 34 3354917 33 3354917 31 3354917 30 3354917 29 3354917 28 3354917 24 3354917 20 3354917 19 3354917 17 3354917 16 3354917 15 3354917 12 3354917 11 3354917 10 3354917 8 3354917 7 3354917 6 3354917 5 3354917 4 3354917 3 3354917 2

For more real estate news, visit longislandpress.com/category/real-estate.

Sign up for Long Island Press’ email newsletters here. Sign up for home delivery of Long Island Press here. Sign up for discounts by becoming a Long Island Press community partner here.