Enchanting Lloyd Harbor Mansion Asks $2.4M


An enchanting Lloyd Harbor mansion situated on a secluded, 2-acre lot is listed for sale.

Located at 49 Harbor Hill Dr., this expansive home is set back from the road, surrounded by trees and shrubbery. A long, private driveway leads to the 7,500-square-foot house, which was built in 1910. The original, classic brick carriage house is a historic, Neo-Georgian style Johnson Estate dubbed “Boatcroft.”

Since its early beginnings, the home has been meticulously expanded and renovated with pristine, modern amenities and interior features while retaining lots of old-world enchantment and charm. The colonial brick house has a modern, rustic interior that’s classy yet inviting. Some features include beautiful oak doors and tall, rounded windows.

When you first walk in, there is a large entrance foyer; a spacious, formal living room; and a library. The first floor also hosts a formal dining room, family room, powder room, and laundry room. Plus, there is a silo bar, an elegant back staircase, and a gourmet, eat-in kitchen featuring gas cooking and high ceilings with custom wood and beams. The kitchen opens to the cozy family room with a fireplace.

The home has a total of six bedrooms, three full bathrooms, and one half bathroom. Most of these are on the second floor, which also houses a gym and a bonus room. The house also has a partial basement with utilities and storage.

Outside, the home has two garage spaces, a walled brick patio area with a kitchen, and picturesque, nature-filled grounds. The landscaping was done by the renowned Olmsted firm, of Central Park fame. 

The single-family home is located in the Cold Spring Harbor School District. It is near a private association beach available to nearby homeowners who pay dues.

The asking price is $2,499,000, not including the annual property tax of $37,857.

The real estate agents listed for the property are Robert Olita and Lynda Olita, of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, who can be reached at 631-549-4400.

3377069 2 3377069 3 3377069 4 3377069 5 3377069 9 3377069 7 3377069 11 3377069 12 3377069 13 3377069 25 3377069 14 3377069 15 3377069 17 3377069 18 3377069 19 3377069 21 3377069 22 3377069 23 3377069 26 3377069 33 3377069 28 3377069 36

For more real estate news, visit longislandpress.com/category/real-estate.

Sign up for Long Island Press’ email newsletters here. Sign up for home delivery of Long Island Press here. Sign up for discounts by becoming a Long Island Press community partner here.